The Whistle Stop Pub Menu
34 items in 6 sections · $3.75 – $7.95 · Restaurant in Islamorada, FL
The Whistle Stop Pub’s menu lists 34 dishes and drinks, grouped into Combo Specials, Soup, Salads, Desserts, Sandwiches and Salad, and Quiche. Prices range from $3.75 to $7.95, and a typical item costs about $3.95. Popular choices include Soup and Sandwich Combo, House Salad, Almond Joy Pie, Tortilla-Every Day, and Chicken Salad.
Combo Specials 1
- Soup and Sandwich Combo$7.25
a half sandwich of your choice, with a cup of soup, chips and your choice of fruit or pasta
Soup 2
- Tortilla-Every Day
our famous tortilla soup is the most popular item on our menu! a mild blend of white chicken with vegetables and herbs, topped with cheese, sour cream and tortilla strips.
- Soup of the Day
ask what soup we are featuring today
Salads 5
- House Salad$5.75
a bed of mixed greens, topped with mushrooms, tomatoes, cucumbers & sprouts with your choice of dressing on the side
- Side Salad$3.75
a small portion of the house salad
- Spinach Salad$6.95
fresh baby spinach with bacon, mushrooms, sliced egg, sprouts and almonds with our special spinach dressing on the side
- Chicken Salad Or Tuna Salad$6.95
a scoop of our famous chicken salad, or, our creamy tuna salad on a bed of mixed greens, surrounded by either fruit or pasta, and topped with sprouts and your choice ofdressing on the side
- Chef Salad$7.95
ham and turkey breast spirals with veggies and cheese on a bed of mixed greens with your choice of dressing on the side
Desserts 19
- Almond Joy Pie$3.95
- Chocolate Fudge Cream Pie$3.95
- Coconut Cream Pie$3.95
- Strawberries & Cream Cake$3.95
- Peaches & Cream Cake$3.95
- Lemon & Cream Cake$3.95
- Raspberry & Cream Cake$3.95
- Peach Cobbler$3.95
- Cherry Crunch$3.95
- Brownie with Fudge Frosting$3.95
- Chocolate Mocha Torte$3.95
- Italian Creme Cake$3.95
- Bread Pudding with Rum Sauce$3.95
- Triple Layer Chocolate Cake$3.95
- Yum Yum Pie$3.95
- Pina Colada Cake$3.95
- Key Lime Pie$3.95
- Cheesecake$3.95
- Ice Cream
Sandwiches and Salad 6
- Chicken Salad
our famous creamy blend of white chicken and our special herb sauce, topped with lettuce and sprouts
- Jalapeno Pimento Cheese
a delicious mix of two cheeses, pimentos and spicy jalapenos
- Ham and Cheese
savory pit ham with swiss american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise & spicy mustard
- Turkey
a stack of smoked turkey breast with swiss american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and spicy mustard
- Tuna Salad
our combination of tuna and our special herb sauce, topped with lettuce and tomato.
- Veggie
a refreshing sandwich made with tomato, cucumber, spinach, lettuce and sprouts with swiss american cheese, mayonnaise and spicy mustard. a refreshing sandwich made with tomato, cucumber, spinach, lettuce and sprouts with swiss american chee
Quiche 1
- Quiche$7.95
a slice of savory quiche served with soup or salad and a side of pasta or fruit, made complete with a slice of our delicious bread. ask about our quiche of the day. (our quiche is a crustless recipe & has hash brown potatoes in the mixture)
How these prices compare
Based on 460 menus with 29,761 priced items from restaurants in Florida, the median menu item costs $12.00, and half of all items are priced between $6.50 and $18.00.
At The Whistle Stop Pub the median listed price is $3.95, lower than the typical $12.00 for restaurants in Florida.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| House Salad | $5.75 | $9.20 |
Typical prices are calculated from 460 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.